Skip to content
signalby Travis Loudin

Type to search.

    manuals /leadership / hard-conversations-and-feedback

    Hard Conversations and Feedback

    by Travis Loudin
    Part 8 of 15field-testedplanted

    Support without honesty slowly turns into enabling. Caring about someone includes telling them what they need to hear, early and kindly.

    Ruinous empathy

    Kim Scott. Radical Candor, 2017.

    What it means

    Being so focused on being nice that you never tell someone the truth. It feels supportive but robs them of the chance to improve.

    In practice

    If you've noticed the same issue three times and haven't said anything, you're overdue.

    “Bad news doesn't get better with age.”

    Common usage

    What it means

    Delayed feedback lands harder and feels like an ambush.

    In practice

    Give corrective feedback within a few days of the moment, while the details are fresh for both of you.

    Situation, Behavior, Impact (SBI)

    Center for Creative Leadership. CCL's feedback model, which it writes as Situation-Behavior-Impact.

    What it means

    Describe when and where, what the person actually did, and the effect it had. It keeps feedback factual instead of personal.

    In practice

    "In Tuesday's standup (situation), you cut off Sam twice (behavior), and he stopped sharing his update (impact)."

    “Seek first to understand, then to be understood.”

    Stephen Covey. Habit 5 in The 7 Habits of Highly Effective People, 1989.

    What it means

    There's usually context you don't have. Hear it before you conclude.

    In practice

    Open with a question: "Walk me through what happened on this one."

    Crucial conversations

    Kerry Patterson, Joseph Grenny, Ron McMillan and Al Switzler. Crucial Conversations: Tools for Talking When Stakes Are High, 2002.

    What it means

    Conversations where stakes are high, opinions differ and emotions run strong. The skill is keeping it safe enough for both people to stay honest.

    In practice

    When someone gets defensive, step back and restate your shared goal before continuing.

    “Feedback is a gift.”

    Common usage

    What it means

    Applies in both directions. Leaders who welcome feedback get more of it and better.

    In practice

    Ask your team regularly, "What's one thing I could do differently that would help you?" Then act on at least some of it visibly.

    Don't let a clear mismatch linger.

    Common usage

    What it means

    Start with your side: were the expectations clear, and did the person get real support and time? Once a mismatch is clear to everyone and coaching hasn't fixed it, don't let it drag on, for the person's sake and the team's. Tolerating it quietly taxes your strongest people, who pick up the slack.

    In practice

    Write down the expectations and the support given, then address it with a clear plan. If what happens next isn't your call, take that record to the person whose call it is. Fairness and speed are not in conflict when the groundwork is done.